ECN brokers act like bridges, directly connecting traders to a vast pool of liquidity providers operating within the interbank market. Beyond simply routing orders to the interbank market, they ensure that traders’ orders are matched and paired with counterparty orders initiated by other traders.
They are the top choice for many traders due to fast execution and reduced conflict of interest, seeing as they are less incentivised to take the opposing side of their clients’ trades.
Here’s our quick comparison of 10 well-renowned ECN Forex brokers at WR Trading, highlighting their core benefits:
Broker:
Execution:
Advantages:
Account:
ECN (Prime, ECN Standard, ECN Institutional)
- No Minimum Deposit
- Spreads from 0.0 Pips
- 26,000+ Markets
- Leverage up to 1:500
- Low Commission from 2$/1 Lot
- High liquidity and fast execution
- TradingView, MT4/5, cTrader, Invest Account
- New Zealand regulated
ECN (Raw ECN)
- 5x regulated broker
- Spreads from 0.0 Pips
- More than 10,000 markets
- Leverage up to 1:500
- Low Commission from 3$/1 Lot
- High liquidity and fast execution
- TradingView, MT4/5, cTrader, IRRES
ECN (Raw ECN)
- ECN Accounts
- Spreads from 0.0 Pips
- Copy Trading available
- Leverage up to 1:500
- Low Commission from 1.5$/1 Lot
- High liquidity and fast execution
- TradingView, MT4/5, cTrader, Pro Trader
ECN
- Different ECN Accounts
- Spreads from 0.0 Pips
- Copy Trading available
- Leverage up to 1:2000
- Low Commission from 6$/1 Lot
- High liquidity and fast execution
- TradingView, MT4/5, cTrader, Pro Trader
ECN (Prime ECN, Ultra ECN)
- ECN/STP Accounts
- Spreads from 0.0 Pips
- Leverage up to 1:1000
- Low Commission from 3$/1 Lot
- High liquidity and fast execution
- MT4/5 and Pro Trader
ECN (Razor Account)
- Tier-1 Regulated Broker
- Spreads from 0.0 Pips
- Leverage up to 1:500 (1:30 EU)
- Low Commission from 3$/1 Lot
- High liquidity and fast execution
- TradingView, MT4/5, cTrader
ECN (Raw Spread)
- Raw Spreads from 0.0 Pips
- Leverage up to 1:500
- Low Commission from 3$/1 Lot
- High liquidity and fast execution
- cTrader, MT4, MT5
ECN (Raw ECN)
- Regulated by multiple authorities
- Spreads from 0.0 Pips
- Leverage up to 1:500
- Commission from $3 per lot
- Fast execution (0.15 sec)
- MT4, MT5, Tickmill App
ECN
- Spreads from 0.0 Pips
- Leverage up to 1:500
- Low Commission from 4$/1 Lot
- High liquidity and fast execution
- TradingView, MT4/5
ECN (Raw ECN)
- Offshore A-Book Broker
- Spreads from 0.0 Pips
- Leverage up to 1:500
- High liquidity and fast execution
- MT4, MT5
Top 10 ECN Forex Brokers
#1 BlackBull Markets
One globally recognised ECN broker is BlackBull Markets, our top pick and winner in this review. Blackbull is appealing to many traders because of its emphasis on transparency and direct access to the market. It offers ECN account types for all levels of experience.
For the active trader, the most popular choice is a Prime account. It has ultra-tight spreads from as low as 0.0 pips, a commission per lot of $6, and a minimum deposit requirement of $2,000 (for Prime accounts only). The following two accounts, ECN Standard and ECN Institutional, are structured slightly differently.
A standard has a minimum spread of 0.8 pips (different from Institutional, which has a minimum of 0.0 pips), no commission charge, and no minimum deposit requirements. The bare-bones cost structure is economical, making it attractive to scalpers and day traders who seek tiny price movements.
Feature | Detail |
---|---|
Account Type | ECN (Prime, ECN Standard, ECN Institutional) |
Trading Platforms | MT4 and/or MT5 |
Minimum Deposit | $2,000 (Prime) |
Regulation | FSA (Seychelles) |
Tradable Instruments | 26,000+ Instruments (Forex, Indices, Commodities, Crypto) |
Spreads | Ultra-tight spreads (from 0.1 pips) |
Commissions | Varies by account (e.g., $6 per lot per side for Prime) |
#2 FP Markets
FP Markets is our second pick among the brokers we’ve reviewed in this piece because of its solid reputation for good ECN forex trading services, with many account options. One of these is the Raw ECN account, which some members of the WR Trading team love. Its razor-thin spreads start from 0.0 pips and a USD3 per side commission, drawing many traders to this account type.
WR Trading particularly values FP Markets’ advocacy for transparency. The broker makes its execution statistics available on its website for traders to consider when judging order execution quality and making significant decisions.
FP Markets supports the trading activities of many traders by requiring a small minimum deposit of AUD$ 100. It provides 24/7 multilingual customer support through telephone, toll-free numbers, and email and has walk-in options at the offices. The office address can be seen on the company’s website.
Feature | Detail |
---|---|
Account Type | ECN (Raw ECN) |
Trading Platforms | MT4 (potentially FP Markets’ own platform) |
Minimum Deposit | AUD$100 |
Regulation | ASIC (Australia), CySEC (Europe), FSCA (South Africa), FSA (Seychelles) |
Tradable Instruments | 10000+ Tradeable Assets, including 70+ Forex Pairs, Indices, Metals, Commodities |
Spreads | Razor-thin spreads (from 0.0 pips) |
Commissions | $3 per side commission |
#3 Vantage Markets
As our third pick among ECN brokers, Vantage Markets stands out in its offering. We advise traders to opt for Vantage Markets’ Raw ECN Account. This account offers a pure ECN experience to clients by using tighter spreads from as low as 0.0 pips with no commission added.
Vantage Markets champions safety and security through its regulation by the VFSC, or Vanuatu Financial Services Commission, in Vanuatu, the FSCA, or Financial Sector Conduct Authority, in South Africa, and the ASIC, or Australian Securities & Investments Commission, in Australia. This ECN broker requires a $50 minimum deposit to open an ECN account. There are no maintenance or inactivity fees with them.
The company caters to various trading styles through popular platforms such as MT4 and MT5 and its Vanatage mobile app. Vantage Markets offers many more markets where a trader could diversify their portfolio: CFDs in shares, ETFs, soft commodities, bonds, indices, and precious metals. Vantage Markets is our second-best because of its multilevel Tier 1 and 2 regulation and affordable minimum deposit requirement.
Feature | Detail |
---|---|
Account Type | ECN (Raw ECN) |
Trading Platforms | MT4, MT5, Vantage Mobile App |
Minimum Deposit | $50 |
Regulation | VFSC (Vanuatu), FSCA (South Africa), ASIC (Australia) |
Tradable Instruments | CFDs on Shares, ETFs, Soft Commodities, Bonds, Indices, Precious Metals |
Spreads | Tight spreads (from 0.0 pips) |
Commissions | $3 commission per 1 LOT (100,000 base currency) |
#4 RoboForex
RoboForex has an ECN account dedicated to professional traders. As our fourth pick at WR Trading, we appreciate its tight spreads from 0.0 pips and $20 in commission per round. The abundance of trading instruments RoboForex offers makes it stand out.
RoboForex offers traders the possibility of diversifying their portfolio in as many as 36 currency pairs, metals, and CFDs. With this extensive range of instruments, RoboForex easily attracts multi-asset traders searching for a single one-stop shop to manage their investments.
For security reasons and to ensure a safe and secure trading environment, RoboForex is regulated by the FSC in Belize. This broker offers ECN accounts with no minimum deposit requirements and supports the MT4 and MT5 platforms.
Feature | Detail |
---|---|
Account Type | ECN |
Trading Platforms | MT4, MT5 |
Minimum Deposit | No minimum |
Regulation | FSC (Belize) |
Tradable Instruments | 36+ Currency Pairs, Metals, CFDs |
Spreads | Tight spreads (from 0.0 pips) |
Commissions | $20 per round commission |
#5 Moneta Markets
As our fifth-best ECN broker, Moneta Markets has grown steadily to become one of the most popular ECN brokers globally. For us at WR Trading, their excellence in teaching their clientele about the markets sets them apart. Hence, their massive library of educational material—video tutorials, market analysis, and live market streams—aims to empower all traders, regardless of experience.
The minimum deposit required in Prime ECN and Ultra ECN account types is $50 and $20,000, respectively. Regarding regulation, Moneta Markets is overseen by the FSCA (Financial Sector Conduct Authority) and the SLIBC (Saint Lucia Registry of International Business Companies).
This broker supports the MT4, MT5, and ProTrader platforms. According to the broker’s specification, traders have access to trade 44 forex pairs, 16 indices, and 19 commodities, together with more than 700 share CFDs, over 30 cryptos, more than 50 ETFs, seven bonds, and CFDs.
Feature | Detail |
---|---|
Account Type | ECN (Prime ECN, Ultra ECN) |
Trading Platforms | MT4, MT5, ProTrader |
Minimum Deposit | $50 (Prime ECN), $20,000 (Ultra ECN) |
Regulation | FSCA (South Africa), SLIBC (Saint Lucia) |
Tradable Instruments | 44 Forex Pairs, 16 Indices, 19 Commodities, 700+ Share CFDs, 30+ Cryptos, 50+ ETFs, 7 Bonds |
Spreads | Tight spreads (from 0.0 pips) |
Commissions | $3 per lot per side (Prime account only) |
#6 Pepperstone
With an excellent ECN execution model and a highly feature-filled, user-friendly interface, Pepperstone has become appealing to many traders. The account types available suit different classes of traders. The Razor Account is one of the more popular ones for us here at WR Trading.
With a commission-based pricing structure, this account type is favoured by scalpers and day traders who would like minimal trading costs. In addition, the Razor account proudly offers ultra-tight spreads starting from 0.0 pips for only $3 per lot per side.
Pepperstone is registered and regulated by the UK’s FCA, ASIC of Australia, and the DFSA of Dubai, the UA, and E for enhanced security measures. Pepperstone does not charge a minimum deposit for opening an ECN account, but it offers trading platforms like MT4, MT5, cTrader, and TradingView. The company provides over 1,200 trading instruments in the indices, commodities, and cryptocurrency classes, enabling traders to access broad trading opportunities.
Feature | Detail |
---|---|
Account Type | ECN (Razor Account) |
Trading Platforms | MT4, MT5, cTrader, Tradingview |
Minimum Deposit | No minimum |
Regulation | FCA (UK), ASIC (Australia), DFSA (Dubai) |
Tradable Instruments | 1,200+ Instruments (Indices, Commodities, Cryptocurrency) |
Spreads | Ultra-tight spreads (from 0.0 pips) |
Commissions | $3 per lot per side commission |
#7 IC Trading
With ultra-tight spreads and execution speed, IC Trading has established itself as an ECN broker among the best available. One thing we love at WR Trading is the company’s setup and excellence in eliminating all possible delays in order processing. This is rather important to scalpers, for whom low latency is paramount.
For such traders, IC Trading has developed the Raw Spread account. The account is commission-based, with spreads as low as 0.0 pips. The Mauritian regulatory body also controls it—the Financial Services Commission, which ensures a safe trading environment, especially for clients from that region. The minimum deposit to open an account is $200.
In addition, this broker offers its traders multiple popular trading platforms like MT4, MT5, and cTrader. IC Trading provides access to a wide range of financial instruments apart from forex, including bonds, indices, futures, stocks, and cryptocurrency, thus engaging everyone in Forex and encouraging portfolio diversification.
Feature | Detail |
---|---|
Account Type | ECN (Raw Spread) |
Trading Platforms | MT4, MT5, cTrader |
Minimum Deposit | $200 |
Regulation | Financial Services Commission (Mauritius) |
Tradable Instruments | Forex, Bonds, Indices, Futures, Stocks, Cryptocurrency |
Spreads | Ultra-tight spreads (from 0.0 pips) |
Commissions | Commission-based (details not specified) |
#8 Tickmill
Tickmill is a trendsetter and reputable ECN broker that is popular among price-sensitive traders. The pricing of the Raw ECN account is very aggressive. It offers ultra-tight spreads starting from 0.0 pips, with a $3 commission per lot per side.
At WR Trading, we applaud how Tickmill provides a secure trading environment while remaining affordable. FCA regulates the broker in the UK, DFSA in the UAE, CySEC in Cyprus, and FSCA in South Africa. This broker’s minimum deposit is $100. Trading platforms such as MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5, MetaTrader WebTrader, and the Tickmill mobile app are also available for this broker.
The company allows traders to expand and diversify into other instruments, such as stock indices, cryptocurrency, and bonds.
Feature | Detail |
---|---|
Account Type | ECN (Raw ECN) |
Trading Platforms | MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, MetaTrader WebTrader, Tickmill Mobile App |
Minimum Deposit | $100 |
Regulation | FCA (UK), DFSA (UAE), CySEC (Cyprus), FSCA (South Africa) |
Tradable Instruments | Stock Indices, Cryptocurrency, Bonds |
Spreads | Ultra-tight spreads (from 0.0 pips) |
Commissions | $3 per lot per side commission |
#9 FBS
While FBS is more oriented to the Forex beginner through other account types, an ECN account is available. Orders are passed on directly to liquidity providers, giving new traders a firsthand view of market dynamics and allowing for tighter spreads.
Our view at WR Trading is that, as much as it has tried to offer an ECN option, FBS does not seem to have the most feature-filled offering. Its orientation toward new traders has resulted in fewer features than those brokers with a specific focus on ECN trading.
Despite this, the FBS ECN account is an apt entry point for new traders who want to get a feel for trading in an ECN environment with the user-friendly platforms MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5. The required minimum deposit to open an ECN account is 5. The FSC—Financial Services Commission—regulates FBS.
Feature | Detail |
---|---|
Account Type | ECN |
Trading Platforms | MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 |
Minimum Deposit | $5 |
Regulation | FSC (Financial Services Commission) |
Tradable Instruments | Forex (limited compared to other ECN brokers) |
Spreads | Potentially tighter spreads compared to other FBS account types |
Commissions | From 0% |
#10 VT Markets
VT Markets has established itself as one of the better internationally acclaimed ECN brokers. Its high personalisation and account management service reflect its solid customer support.
Besides customer service, VT Markets offers a smooth trading experience. It gives access to popular trading platforms like MetaTrader 4 and 5 and facilitates different trading styles through available account options. The Raw ECN account is better suited for most traders; it is commission-based, set at $6 per round turn, with very tight spreads from as low as 0.0 pips and a minimum deposit of $100.
VT Markets is regulated by ASIC, FSCA, and the FSC for financial safety and security in Australia, South Africa, and Mauritius, respectively. Regarding tradable instruments, VT Markets offers Forex pairs, CFDs, indices, and commodities.
Feature | Detail |
---|---|
Account Type | ECN (Raw ECN) |
Trading Platforms | MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 |
Minimum Deposit | $100 |
Regulation | ASIC (Australia), FSCA (South Africa), FSC (Mauritius) |
Tradable Instruments | Forex Pairs, CFDs, Indices, Commodities |
Spreads | Very tight spreads (from 0.0 pips) |
Commissions | $6 per round turn commission |
What Is an ECN Broker in Detail?
An ECN broker is simply an Electronic Communication Network broker who links a retail trader through an electronic medium to a large pool of liquidity providers in the interbank market. Examples include big banks, hedge funds, and several other institutional players. There are various benefits of trading with ECN brokers:
- Potentially tighter spreads: An ECN broker typically has tighter spreads than a dealership broker, otherwise referred to as a market maker. This is because the prices originate from the liquidity providers, indicating changes in demand and supply within the market over time.
- Less conflict of interest: With ECN brokers, there are very few conflicts of interest. Since an ECN broker does not take the other side of your trade, it is in their best interest to pass on the best possible price to you.
- Faster execution of orders: Since orders are matched automatically by electronic pairing within the network, traders can have faster order execution times with ECN brokers. This is quite useful for scalpers and day traders.
The Electronic Communications Network Explained
An ECN is an electronic system used in the marketplace to connect buyers and sellers. Forex trading refers to the network through which brokers link a retail trader to liquidity providers. Here’s how:
- Order placement by trader: A trader will log a buy or sell order in the trading platform provided by the ECN broker.
- Order dissemination: The ECN broker broadcasts the order electronically to the pool of liquidity providers in the network.
- Price Matching: This allows your order to be matched with the best available counteroffer posted by any liquidity provider.
- Order execution: In the case of a matching offer, a trade is executed at the agreed price.
Pros and Cons of ECN Brokers
Understanding the benefits and pitfalls of financially worthy or significant efforts is critical. Similarly, examine the advantages and disadvantages of trading using ECN brokers before you begin.
Pros
- Potentially tighter spreads
- Trades get executed at the next available price without requotes
- Reduced conflict of interest
- Faster order execution
- Greater transparency on execution statistics and commission structure
Cons
- ECN brokers typically charge commissions on each trade
- Higher minimum deposit requirements compared to dealing desk brokers
- Less hand-holding compared to some dealing desk brokers, who may provide research reports and trading signals
No Conflict of Interest Between ECN Brokers and Traders
One of the primary advantages of ECN brokers is that they have less conflict of interest. An ECN broker does not act as a dealing desk broker or market maker who quotes prices to the trader with the motive of making a profit from spreads. On the other hand, an ECN Broker links a trader directly or through participants to interbank markets.
ECN Brokers charge commissions according to the number of trades executed. Therefore, managing your order effectively is in the broker’s best interest. The broker earns through commissions charged per trade rather than profiting from spread manipulation. The right trading broker saves costs and ensures quick order execution.
Is ECN Trading via an A-Book?
Yes, most ECN brokers can be considered A-book brokers since they use the A-booking system. However, some may use a hybrid model, potentially routing a small portion of client orders internally for risk management. It’s crucial to choose an ECN broker that is transparent about its order execution policies.
The terms “ECN broker” and “A-book broker” are often used interchangeably, but there’s a subtle distinction.
- ECN Broker: This refers to the execution model, in which the broker connects traders directly with liquidity providers in the interbank market.
- A-Book Broker: Refers to the way the broker handles client orders. An A-book broker typically routes most, if not all, client orders directly to the interbank market without taking the opposite side of the trade themselves.
Is an ECN Broker Using a B-Book?
No, an actual ECN broker would not use a B-book model.
B-Book Broker (Market Maker): This broker takes the opposing side of your trade. They quote prices based on their inventory or sources of liquidity, which also means they are interested in the result. A B-book broker may widen spreads or engage in requotes to profit from the difference between the bid and ask price.
ECN brokers may sometimes route orders internally for risk management. However, the core of their core business must direct orders to the interbank market via an electronic network.
ECN Broker vs Dealing Desk Brokers (Market Makers)
Here’s a more detailed comparison of ECN brokers and dealing desk brokers (market makers):
Feature | ECN Broker | Dealing Desk Broker (Market Maker) |
---|---|---|
Execution Model | Connects traders with liquidity providers | Maybe wider |
Conflict of Interest | Lower | Higher |
Spreads | Potentially tighter | May be wider |
Commissions | Often charged | May not be charged |
Order Execution | Faster (electronic matching) | It may be slower (manual intervention) |
Transparency | Generally higher | Generally lower |
Conclusion
Choosing the right Forex broker is a critical decision that can significantly impact your trading experience. ECN brokers offer several advantages. However, they also typically charge commissions and may have higher minimum deposit requirements.
WR Trading recommends carefully considering your trading style and budget when selecting an ECN broker.
Once again, these are the 10 best ECN Forex brokers:
- BlackBull Markets – Transparency and Innovation with tailored account types for traders
- FP Markets – Razor-thin spreads from 0.0 pips and high transparency
- Vantage Markets – Streamlined ECN experience with account options for various needs
- RoboForex – Feature-rich platform catering to multi-asset traders
- Moneta Markets – Focus on education and resources for traders
- Pepperstone – Globally recognised powerhouse offering a user-friendly platform and tight spreads
- IC Trading – Leader in scalping with tight spreads and fast execution
- Tickmill – A cost-effective option with competitive commissions
- FBS – Beginner-friendly with educational resources (not a pure ECN model)
- VT Markets – Exceptional customer service, Raw ECN account with tight spreads
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is an ECN Broker Right for Me?
An ECN broker is best for traders seeking tight spreads, fast execution, and transparency. So, if this matches your needs, an ECN broker is right for you.
Is it Safe to Trade With an ECN Broker?
Yes, it is generally safe to trade with an ECN broker. However, safety also depends on the broker’s regulation. Be sure to look for an ECN or no-dealing-desk broker regulated by reputed financial authorities like ASIC, FCA, or CySEC.
How Much Does it Cost to Trade with an ECN Broker?
The usual commission charged is per round turn. These commissions vary from broker to broker and also by the type of account one holds. Some ECN brokers may also have a minimum initial deposit requirement. Most ECN brokers will plainly state this on their websites.
What Platform Do ECN Brokers Use?
Most ECN brokers offer trading platforms like MT4 and MT5. They have features and functionalities that any trader would need for Forex trading.
What Are Some of the Challenges of Trading with an ECN Broker?
Some ECN brokers’ commissions could turn off some new traders. In addition, some dealing desk brokers provide more guidance than ECN brokers.
How Can I Compare Different ECN Brokers?
Look at spreads, commissions, minimum deposit required, available trading platforms, customer service, regulation, and educational resources.
Resources
- https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/foreign-exchange/ecn-broker/
- https://www.vantagemarkets.com/trading/accounts/raw-ecn/#:~:text=The%20minimum%20recommended%20amount%20for,deposit%20amount%20is%20USD%2450.
- https://blackbull.com/en/our-company/account-comparison/
- https://www.vtmarkets.com/regulation/